Mellow Mushroom Reviews

Mellow Mushroom has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 60 reviews. Customer feedback on Mellow Mushroom is mixed: Mellow Mushroom reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, unique toppings, friendly service, vibrant atmosphere, which strongly appeal to pizza lovers, families, casual diners, college students. However, Mellow Mushroom is often criticized for its high prices, inconsistent service, long wait times, limited parking.

3.8/5.0

60 reviews

5 Stars

16

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

6

1 Star

2

All Mellow Mushroom Reviews (60)
mikkinichols6828
May 24, 2026
"I came in expecting it to be..."
I came in expecting it to be easy to find vegan or vegetarian options, but based on my visit, this doesn’t really seem like the kind of place that’s set up well for plant-based eating. The choices felt limited, and the staff didn’t seem totally sure about what was in some of the dishes. The food I did get was just okay, but I probably wouldn’t come back here for vegan options.
MOONEY
May 15, 2026
"Ordering online was really quick and simple..."
Ordering online was really quick and simple (which I always appreciate). No hassle at all from start to finish.
SherryDunnam
May 06, 2026
"Clean and Comfortable"
The tables and bathrooms seemed clean, and the floors looked well taken care of too. it kind of made the whole meal feel a little nicer.
Irene.cassidy
April 25, 2026
"Good pizza despite the noise"
It was a bit noisy when I went, which made it kind of hard to fully relax, you know? But the pizza was still really good, so I feel like that kind of made up for it. I’d probably go back, especially if it’s a little quieter next time...
richard_Lewis76
April 19, 2026
"Friendly, Chill Spot"
I had a really nice experience ordering from Mellow Mushroom. The staff was super friendly and never made us feel rushed, even when we had a few questions. Our server checked in the right amount and was easy to talk to. I feel like other customers would appreciate the laid-back vibe too, it’s just a chill place with good people working there
CliffordJenkins
April 16, 2026
"Nice, attentive service"
The staff were really attentive without making a big fuss. Just a smooth, pleasant experience overall.
charles_Scott77
April 15, 2026
"Pretty decent, just not super memorable"
The drink options were decent overall. The beer list seemed fine, and the cocktails were okay, though a little basic. Nothing was bad by any means, I just kind of expected a bit more variety or something that stood out more. It’s probably a solid enough spot if you’re not too picky.
Leonel_green79
April 10, 2026
"I ordered pizza for delivery and I’ll…"
I ordered pizza for delivery and I’ll admit I was starting to worry a little when it didn’t show up by the estimated time. I’ve been burned before with late deliveries, so for a minute I wondered if I was getting fooled or if something had gone wrong. Thankfully it arrived not too much later, still warm, and it tasted really good. The driver was friendly and everything was packed properly. I’m only taking off one star because of the wait
jillscott3686
April 06, 2026
"Way quicker than I thought it’d be"
I ordered through mellowmushroom.com and, I don’t know, the whole thing just felt surprisingly smooth. The site was simple enough to use, but what really got me was how fast the food was ready. It was one of those little things that just makes you weirdly happy.
When I went to pick it up, I barely had to wait at all, which never seems to happen with pizza around here. The food was still hot too, so the whole experience just left me feeling really good about it. Easy 5 stars for the quick service.
sonja1997
April 05, 2026
"Couldn’t even park to pick it up"
I went to pick up my order and ended up circling around looking for parking forever. Couldn’t find a spot anywhere, got frustrated, and just left. They can say whatever they want about things being “easy” or “convenient,” but that wasn’t my experience at all.
MANCE
March 18, 2026
"Apps didn’t really meet my standards"
I’m usually easygoing, but I do expect appetizers to come out hot and fresh. The mozzarella bites were soggy and kind of cold, so they just didn’t feel worth the price to me.
hello_june840
March 10, 2026
"Not the easiest spot with kids"
The food was okay, nothing bad, but it didn’t really feel like a great place for families. It was loud, the service was a little slow, and there wasn’t much to keep the kids occupied while we waited... Maybe it’s a better fit for adults, but with kids along, it felt more stressful than enjoyable.
michael1972
March 07, 2026
"I like going to Mellow Mushroom…"
I like going to Mellow Mushroom mostly because it’s just really convenient for me. It’s close to the places I’m usually around, so it’s kind of become one of those easy spots I think of when I don’t want to make a whole plan just to grab food. Parking has always been simple when I’ve gone, which I really appreciate, and the location is easy to find without any confusing turns or awkward entrances. It’s a solid casual place for me when I want something good and don’t feel like driving all over town.
darrenvanwart5474
February 26, 2026
"Good delivery overall"
Ordered delivery from Mellow Mushroom and everything was right, even the extra sauce, which I appreciated. The food showed up in good shape too. I’m taking off one star because it was a little later than expected, but it really wasn’t a huge deal in the end.
John-sanderson
February 24, 2026
"I usually go to Mellow Mushroom…"
I usually go to Mellow Mushroom with pizza on the brain, but I tried the Greek salad this time and felt like I made a solid choice. Small win for me because I was trying to eat something a little lighter, and it didn’t feel like I was settling at all. The lettuce was crisp, the toppings tasted fresh, and there was plenty of cheese, olives, and dressing without it being soaked. The portion was bigger than I expected too. Simple, tasty, and definitely something I’d order again
JimmyDowney_65
February 23, 2026
"Fresh Toppings and a Solid Pizza Night"
Ordered from Mellow Mushroom the toppings tasted really fresh, especially the mushrooms and peppers. The pizza came out good and wasn’t soggy at all, which I really liked. I’m giving it 4 stars just because the crust was a little too chewy for me, but overall it was still a solid pizza night.
violette1970
February 15, 2026
"Good Food, Frustrating Wait"
The food was actually good, but the wait took forever. What made it more frustrating was that when I asked about it, I kept getting the usual “it’s our policy” type of excuse instead of a real explanation or any attempt to help. I wouldn’t have minded the delay as much if they’d just been upfront about it.
Arlene_miles96
February 14, 2026
"Ordered a pepperoni pizza it just didn’t…"
Ordered a pepperoni pizza it just didn’t do it for me. The crust was weirdly chewy, and the sauce had this sweet taste without much actual flavor. The toppings were fine, I guess, but overall it felt bland for what I paid. What annoyed me too was that the communication wasn’t very clear, so I wasn’t really sure what to expect with the order. Maybe some people like their pizza this way, but I left let down and probably won’t be rushing back.
giovannavoyer1085
February 08, 2026
"The seats were way comfier than I…"
The seats were way comfier than I expected. I only planned to pop in for a bit, but I ended up staying way longer lol. Sure they know exactly what they’re doing making the place that cozy.
hello_wanda985
February 05, 2026
"Left Happy and Full"
I was in a relaxed mood when I went in, the food hit the spot. I left totally full and still had a few slices to take home for later, which was a nice bonus...

View More Reviews

Mellow Mushroom Q&A

How do I find out their specials or discounts?

Have a question about Mellow Mushroom?
mellowmushroom

Mellow Mushroom Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.